2024: Maarten Paes – FC Dallas 5/29/24 vs. LA Galaxy, 32'
2023: Roman Celentano – FC Cincinnati 5/20/23 vs. Columbus Crew, 90'
2022: Pedro Gallese – Orlando City SC 7/17/22 vs. Atlanta United, 82'
2021: Stefan Frei – Seattle Sounders FC 9/18/21 vs. Real Salt Lake, 57'
2020: Eloy Room – Columbus Crew 11/4/20 vs. Orlando City SC, 30'
2019: Nick Rimando – Real Salt Lake 8/24/19 vs. Colorado Rapids, 27'
2018: Stefan Frei – Seattle Sounders FC 7/4/18 vs. Colorado Rapids, 82'
2017: Brad Guzan – Atlanta United 10/15/17 vs. New York Red Bulls, 65'
2016: Joe Bendik – Orlando City SC 5/15/16 vs. Sporting Kansas City, 45'
2015: Adam Kwarasey – Portland Timbers 8/15/15 vs. Real Salt Lake, 31'
2014: Luis Robles – New York Red Bulls 9/20/14 vs. Seattle Sounders FC, 69'
2013: Nick Rimando – Real Salt Lake 8/3/13 vs. Colorado Rapids, 53'
2012: Nick Rimando – Real Salt Lake 4/14/12 vs. Sporting Kansas City, 75'
2011: Kasey Keller – Seattle Sounders FC 10/15/11 vs. San Jose Earthquakes, 64'
2010: Kasey Keller – Seattle Sounders FC 4/17/10 vs. Kansas City Wizards, 90'
2009: Pat Onstad – Houston Dynamo FC 4/19/09 vs. Colorado Rapids, 83'
(Tribunnews.com/Bayu Panegak)